Argentina’s Seed Law

By Adrian Gonzalez. Patents Engineer.

The proposal of the Argentine National Government for a package of laws and reforms includes a change in the Argentine Seed Law from UPOV 78 to UPOV 91. This implies significant changes in the Argentine Seed Law in favor of the breeder, which would be controversial if adopted, considering the current exceptions for farmers.

A comparative table between UPOV 78, UPOV 91 and Patent Laws is attached:

Provision
UPOV 1978
UPOV 1991 Act
TRIPS compatible Patent Laws
Protection coverage
Varieties of species / genera as listed. Minimum of fi ve on joining. 24 after 8 years Minimum of fi fteen on joining. 10 years
later, must protect all plant genera and
species
Inventions
Requirement
Novelty (variety must not have been commercialized) Novelty (variety must not have been commercialized) Novelty (invention must not have been published) Distinctness Distinctness Non-obviousnes
Distinctness Distinctness Non-obviousness (Inventiveness)
Sufficient uniformity having regard to the particular features of the variety’s propagation Sufficient uniformity having regard to the particular features of the variety’s propagation Industrial applicability (usefulness)
Stability Stability
Protection term
Minimum 15 years (18 years for trees and vines) Minimum 20 years (25 years for trees and vines) Minimum 20 years (TRIPS)
Protection scope
Production for commercial purposes and offering for sale, marketing and repeated use for the commercial production of another variety Commercial transactions with propagating material. Harvested material protected only if produced from propagating material without breeder’s permission and if breeder had no reasonable chance to exploit his right over it. Making the patented product, using the patented process or using, offering for sale, selling or importing for those purposes the patented product obtained by the patented process
Breeders’ exemption
Mandatory. Breeders free to use protected variety to develop new variety Permissive but Essentially Derived Varieties can only be marketed with the agreement of the breeder No
Farmers’ privilege
Minimum scope of protection allows farmers’ privilege Each member country can define a farmers’ privilege suitable for its condition No
Any species eligible for PBR protection cannot be patented This Act is silent on this question: countries may choose to exclude plant varieties from patent protection Many countries exclude plant varieties as such from patent protection

https://www.fao.org/3/y5714e/y5714e03.htm

The Argentine Seed Law of 1978 established a series of rights for farmers, such as the right to use their seeds for subsequent planting. However, the Argentine Seed Law of 1991 could restrict these rights.

The main difference between the Argentine Seed Law of 1978 and 1991 are as follows:

UPOV 91 could:

  • Restrict farmers’ rights to freely use their seeds.
  • Allow varieties to be patented.
  • Extend breeders’ rights to “harvested material” in case of unauthorized use of the propagation material.
  • Require anyone using a PVP (Plant Variety Protection) variety in breeding to make major changes so tha the “new” variety is not considered “essentially derived” and falls into the ownership of the first breeder.

The Argentine Seed Law is a complex issue with important implications for farmers, breeders and the food industry in general.

Share
Abrir o Whatsapp
Olá e bem-vindo à Moeller IP! 🚀 Um prazer nos conectar com você no dinâmico mundo da Propriedade Intelectual na América Latina.

🌟 Sobre nós: A Moeller IP é uma empresa líder com uma forte presença no Brasil, México, Argentina, Uruguai e em toda a região latino-americana. Estamos dedicados a proteger e maximizar o valor de seus ativos intelectuais.

💬 Como podemos ajudar: Por favor, nos informe como podemos ajudar, e entraremos em contato com você com as informações necessárias.